A team of astronomers led by Dr. István Szapudi of the Institute for Astronomy at the University of Hawaii at Manoa may have found an explanation for the existence of the Cold Spot, which Szapudi says may be "the largest individual structure ever identified by humanity." Read more
Title: A Detection of the Cold Imprint of Voids on the Microwave Background Radiation Authors: Yan-Chuan Cai (Durham), Mark C. Neyrinck (JHU), Istvan Szapudi (IfA Hawaii), Shaun Cole (Durham), Carlos S. Frenk (Durham)
We measure the average cold spot on the cosmic microwave background(CMB) produced by voids selected in the SDSS DR7 spectroscopic redshift galaxy catalogue, spanning redshifts from 0 to 0.4. Our detection has a significance of ~3sigma based on the variance of random samples, and has an average amplitude of ~3 muK as viewed through a compensated top-hat filter scaled to the radius of each void. This signal, if interpreted as the late-time Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect, serves as an evidence for the late-time acceleration of the Universe. The detection is achieved by applying the optimal filter size identified from N-body simulations. Two striking features are found by comparing ISW simulations with our detection, 1.) the void profiles traced by halos in our simulations are very similar to those in the data traced by galaxies. 2.) the same filter radius that gives the largest ISW signal in simulations also yields the largest detected signal in the observations. We model the expected ISW signal using voids from N-body simulations in LCDM, selected in the same way as in the observations. The detected signal, however, is many times larger than that from simulations, discrepant at the ~3sigma level. The large cosmic variance of large-scale modes in the gravitational potential can obscure an ISW measurement such as ours. However, we show how this cosmic variance can be effectively reduced by using a compensated top-hat filter for the detection. We test whether a few possible systematic effects could be producing the signal; we find no evidence that they do.
Title: Local properties of WMAP Cold Spot Authors: Wen Zhao
We investigate the local properties of WMAP Cold Spot (CS) localised at (l=209°, b=-57°) in Galactic Coordinate by defining the local statistics: mean temperature, variance, skewness and kurtosis. Comparing with the Gaussian random simulations, as well as the other spots in WMAP data, we find that the local mean temperatures around CS are quite lower in the scale of R\lesssim5° as expected. In particular, we also find that the values of local variance and skewness around CS are all systematically larger in the scale of R>5°, which implies that WMAP CS is prefer a large-scale non-Gaussian structure to a combination of some small structures. The non-Gaussianity of CS is totally encoded in the WMAP low multipoles at l\le 40. We also find that the cosmic texture can excellently explain all the excesses in these statistics. So the local analysis of the WMAP CS supports the cosmic texture explanation.
Title: A Theory of a Spot Authors: Niayesh Afshordi (Perimeter/Waterloo), Ane Slosar (Brookhaven), Yi Wang (McGill) (Version v2)
We present a simple inflationary scenario that can produce arbitrarily large spherical underdense or overdense regions embedded in a standard Lambda cold dark matter paradigm, which we refer to as bubbles. We analyse the effect such bubbles would have on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). For super-horizon sized bubble in the vicinity of the last scattering surface, a signal is imprinted onto CMB via a combination of Sach-Wolfe and an early integrated Sach-Wolfe (ISW) effects. Smaller, sub-horizon sized bubbles at lower redshifts (during matter domination and later) can imprint secondary anisotropies on the CMB via Rees-Sciama, late-time ISW and Ostriker-Vishniac effects. Our scenario, and arguably most similar inflationary models, produce bubbles which are over/underdense in potential: in density such bubbles are characterized by having a distinct wall with the interior staying at the cosmic mean density. We show that such models can potentially, with only moderate fine tuning, explain the cold spot, a non-Gaussian feature identified in the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) data by several authors. However, more detailed comparisons with current and future CMB data are necessary to confirm (or rule out) this scenario.
Title: Polarising Bubble Collisions Authors: Bartlomiej Czech, Matthew Kleban, Klaus Larjo, Thomas S. Levi, Kris Sigurdson
We predict the polarisation of cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons that results from a cosmic bubble collision. The polarization is purely E-mode, symmetric around the axis pointing towards the collision bubble, and has several salient features in its radial dependence that can help distinguish it from a more conventional explanation for unusually cold or hot features in the CMB sky. The anomalous "cold spot" detected by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) satellite is a candidate for a feature produced by such a collision, and the Planck satellite and other proposed surveys will measure the polarisation on it in the near future. The detection of such a collision would provide compelling evidence for the string theory landscape.
Title: The Cold Spot as a Large Void: Lensing Effect on CMB Two and Three Point Correlation Functions Authors: Isabella Masina, Alessio Notari (Version v3)
The "Cold Spot" in the CMB sky could be due to the presence of an anomalous huge spherical underdense region - a "Void" - of a few hundreds Mpc/h radius. Such a structure would have an impact on the CMB two-point (power spectrum) and three-point (bispectrum) correlation functions not only at low-l, but also at high-l through Lensing, which is a unique signature of a Void. Modelling such an underdensity with an LTB metric, we show that for the power spectrum the effect should be visible already in the WMAP data only if the Void radius is at least L \gtrsim 1 Gpc/h, while it will be visible by the Planck satellite if L \gtrsim 500 Mpc/h. We also speculate that this could be linked to the high-l detection of an hemispherical power asymmetry in the sky. Moreover, there should be non-zero correlations in the non-diagonal two-point function. For the bispectrum, the effect becomes important for squeezed triangles with two very high l's: this signal can be detected by Planck if the Void radius is at least L \gtrsim 300 Mpc/h, while higher resolution experiments should be able to probe the entire parameter space. We have also estimated the contamination of the primordial non-Gaussianity f_NL due to this signal, which turns out to be negligible.
Cosmic bubble made cold spot in big bang afterglow
A bubble of space that expanded differently to the rest of the early universe could explain a strange "cold spot" in the afterglow of the big bang. Such bubbles might have formed just fractions of a second after the universe came into existence, when it grew dramatically in size.
"It would be an unexpected gift, because we would all of a sudden have a very good window on inflation" - Ane Slosar of the Brookhaven National Laboratory in Upton, New York, part of the team that put forward the idea.
Title: A Theory of a Spot Authors: Niayesh Afshordi (Perimeter/Waterloo), Ane Slosar (Brookhaven), Yi Wang (McGill)
present a simple model of inflation that can produce arbitrarily large spherical underdense or overdense regions embedded in a standard Lambda cold dark matter paradigm, which we refer to as bubbles. We analyse the effect such bubbles would have on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). For super-horizon sized bubble in the vicinity of the last scattering surface, a signal is imprinted onto CMB via a combination of Sach-Wolfe and an early integrated Sach-Wolfe (ISW) effects. Smaller, sub-horizon sized bubbles at lower redshifts (during matter domination and later) can imprint secondary anisotropies on the CMB via Rees-Sciama, late-time ISW and Ostriker-Vishniac effects. Our model, and arguably most similar inflationary models, produce bubbles which are over/underdense in potential: in density such bubbles are characterized by having a distinct wall with the interior staying at the cosmic mean density. We show that such models can, with only moderate fine tuning, explain the cold spot, a non-Gaussian feature identified in the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) data by several authors.
Title: Disks in the sky: A reassessment of the WMAP "cold spot" Authors: Ray Zhang, Dragan Huterer (University of Michigan) (Version v2)
We reassess the evidence that WMAP temperature maps contain a statistically significant "cold spot" by repeating the analysis using simple circular top-hat (disk) weights, as well as Gaussian weights of varying width. Contrary to previous results that used Spherical Mexican Hat Wavelets, we find no significant signal at any scale when we compare the coldest spot from our sky to ones from simulated Gaussian random, isotropic maps. We trace this apparent discrepancy to the fact that WMAP cold spot's temperature profile just happens to favour the particular profile given by the wavelet. Since randomly generated maps typically do not exhibit this coincidence, we conclude that the original cold spot significance originated at least partly due to a fortuitous choice of using a particular basis of weight functions. We also examine significance of a more general measure that returns the most significant result among several choices of the weighting function, angular scale of the spot, and the statistics applied, and again find a null result.