Title: A correlation between the heavy element content of transiting extrasolar planets and the metallicity of their parent stars Authors: Tristan Guillot, Nuno C. Santos, Frederic Pont, Nicolas Iro, Claudio Melo, and Ignasi Ribas
Abstract: Nine extrasolar planets with masses between 110 and 430 earth masses are known to transit their star. The knowledge of their masses and radii allows an estimate of their composition, but uncertainties on equations of state, opacities and possible missing energy sources imply that only inaccurate constraints can be derived when considering each planet separately.
A team of European astronomers, led by T. Guillot (CNRS, Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur, France), will publish a new study of the physics of Pegasids (also known as hot Jupiters) in Astronomy & Astrophysics. They found that the amount of heavy elements in Pegasids is correlated to the metallicity of their parent stars. This is a first step in understanding the physical nature of the extrasolar planets.
Up to now, astronomers have discovered 188 extrasolar planets, among which 10 are known as “transiting planets”. These planets pass between their star and us at each orbit. Given the current technical limitations, the only transiting planets that can be detected are giant planets orbiting close to their parent star known as “hot Jupiters” or Pegasids. The ten transiting planets known thus far have masses between 110 and 430 Earth masses (for comparison, Jupiter, with 318 Earth masses, is the most massive planet in our Solar System). Although rare, transiting planets are the key to understanding planetary formation because they are the only ones for which both the mass and radius can be determined. In principle, the obtained mean density can constrain their global composition. However, translating a mean density into a global composition needs accurate models of the internal structure and evolution of planets.
The situation is made difficult by our relatively poor knowledge of the behaviour of matter at high pressures (the pressure in the interiors of giant planets is more than a million times the atmospheric pressure on Earth). Of the nine transiting planets known up to April 2006, only the least massive one could have its global composition determined satisfactorily. It was shown to possess a massive core of heavy elements, about 70 times the mass of the Earth, with a 40 Earth-mass envelope of hydrogen and helium. Of the remaining eight planets, six were found to be mostly made up of hydrogen and helium, like Jupiter and Saturn, but their core mass could not be determined. The last two were found to be too large to be explained by simple models.
Considering them as an ensemble for the first time, and accounting for the anomalously large planets, Tristan Guillot and his team found that the nine transiting planets have homogeneous properties, with a core mass ranging from 0 (no core, or a small one) up to 100 times the mass of the Earth, and a surrounding envelope of hydrogen and helium. Some of the Pegasids should therefore contain larger amounts of heavy elements than expected. When comparing the mass of heavy elements in the Pegasids to the metallicity of the parent stars, they also found a correlation to exist, with planets born around stars that are as metal-rich as our Sun and that have small cores, while planets orbiting stars that contain two to three times more metals have much larger cores. Their results will be published in Astronomy & Astrophysics.
Planet formation models have failed to predict the large amounts of heavy elements found this way in many planets, so these results imply that they need revising. The correlation between stellar and planetary composition has to be confirmed by further discoveries of transiting planets, but this work is a first step in studying the physical nature of extrasolar planets and their formation. It would explain why transiting planets are so hard to find, to start with. Because most Pegasids have relatively large cores, they are smaller than expected and more difficult to detect in transit in front of their stars. In any case, this is very promising for the CNES space mission COROT to be launched in October, which should discover and lead to characterization of tens of transiting planets, including smaller planets and planets orbiting too far from their star to be detected from the ground. What of the tenth transiting planet? XO-1b (see above) was announced very recently and is also found to be an anomalously large planet orbiting a star of solar metallicity. Models imply that it has a very small core, so that this new discovery strengthens the proposed stellar-planetary metallicity correlation.
The team includes T. Guillot (France), N.C. Santos (Portugal), F. Pont (Switzerland), N. Iro (USA), C. Melo (Germany), I. Ribas (Spain).
"This web page describes contributions to the study of the XO-1 exoplanet system by observations with the Hereford Arizona Observatory 14-inch (Ed - MEADE ) amateur telescope during the 11 months preceding the Space Telescope Science Institute press release on May 18, 2006. The goal is to encourage other amateurs to refine their observing and data analysis techniques so that they can contribute quality observations for use in the study of this interesting extra-solar system. A companion web page gives details of a successful transit observation on March 14, 2006 that I use for a "how to" case study tutorial. It illustrates my belief that the two most important considerations for achieving good exoplanet transit data are: 1) keep the star field fixed to the same location on the CCD chip for the entire observing session, and 2) use an R-filter."
The star XO-1 is located in the constellation Corona Borealis, at RA = 16:02:11.6, Dec = +28:10:11.
ASTRONOMERS USE INNOVATIVE TECHNIQUE TO FIND EXTRASOLAR PLANET
An international team of professional and amateur astronomers, using simple off-the-shelf equipment to trawl the skies for planets outside our solar system, has hauled in its first "catch."
The astronomers discovered a Jupiter-sized planet orbiting a Sun-like star 600 light-years from Earth in the constellation Corona Borealis. The team, led by Peter McCullough of the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore, Md., includes four amateur astronomers from North America and Europe.
Using modest telescopes to search for extrasolar planets allows for a productive collaboration between professional and amateur astronomers that could accelerate the planet quest.
"This discovery suggests that a fleet of modest telescopes and the help of amateur astronomers can search for transiting extrasolar planets many times faster than we are now" - Peter McCullough .
The finding has been accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal.
McCullough deployed a relatively inexpensive telescope made from commercial equipment to scan the skies for extrasolar planets. Called the XO telescope, it consists of two 200-millimeter telephoto camera lenses and looks like a pair of binoculars. The telescope is on the summit of the Haleakala volcano, in Hawaii. McCullough's team found the planet, dubbed X0-1b, by noticing slight dips in the star's light output when the planet passed in front of the star, called a transit. The light from the star, called XO-1, dips by approximately 2 percent when the planet XO-1b passes in front of it. The observation also revealed that X0-1b is in a tight four-day orbit around its parent star.
Although astronomers have detected more than 180 extrasolar planets, X0-1b is only the tenth planet discovered using the transit method. It is the second planet found using telephoto lenses. The first, dubbed TrES-1, was reported in 2004. The transit method allows astronomers to determine a planet's mass and size. Astronomers use this information to deduce the planet's characteristics, such as its density. The team confirmed the planet's existence by using the Harlan J. Smith Telescope and the Hobby-Eberly Telescope at the University of Texas's McDonald Observatory to measure the slight wobble induced by the planet on its parent star. This so-called radial-velocity method allowed the team to calculate a precise mass for the planet, which is slightly less than that of Jupiter (about 0.9 Jupiter masses). The planet also is much larger than its mass would suggest.
"Of the planets that pass in front of their stars, XO-1b is the most similar to Jupiter yet known, and the star XO-1 is the most similar to the Sun; but XO-1b is much, much closer to its star than Jupiter is to the Sun." - Peter McCullough.
Position (2000): R.A. 16h 02m 11s.84 Dec. +28° 10' 10".4
The astronomer's innovative technique of using relatively inexpensive telescopes to look for eclipsing planets favours finding planets orbiting close to their parent stars. The planet also must be large enough to produce a measurable dip in starlight. The planet is the first discovered in McCullough's three-year search for transiting extrasolar planets. The planet quest is underwritten by a grant from NASA's Origins program. McCullough's planet-finding technique involves nightly sweeps of the sky using the XO telescope in Hawaii to note the brightness of the stars it encounters. A computer software program sifts through many thousands of stars every two months looking for tiny dips in the stars' light, the signature of a possible planetary transit. The computer comes up with a few hundred possibilities. From those candidates, McCullough and his team select a few dozen promising leads. He passes these stars on to the four amateur astronomers to study the possible transits more carefully.
From September 2003 to September 2005, the XO telescope observed tens of thousands of bright stars. In that time, his team of amateur astronomers studied a few dozen promising candidate stars identified by McCullough and his team. The star X0-1 was pegged as a promising candidate in June 2005. The amateur astronomers observed it in June and July 2005, confirming that a planet-sized object was eclipsing the star. McCullough's team then turned to the McDonald Observatory in Texas to obtain the object's mass and verify it as a planet. He received the news of the telescope's observation at 12:06 a.m. Feb. 16, 2006, from Chris Johns-Krull, a friend and colleague at Rice University.
"It was a wonderful feeling because the team had worked for three years to find this one planet. The discovery represents a few bytes out of nearly a terabyte of data: It's like trying to distil gold out of seawater." - Peter McCullough.
The discovery also has special familial significance for the astronomer.
"My father's mentor was Harlan J. Smith, the man whose ambition and hard work produced the telescope that we used to acquire the verifying data." - Peter McCullough.
McCullough believes the newly found planet is a perfect candidate for study by the Hubble and Spitzer space telescopes. Hubble can measure precisely the star's distance and the planet's size. Spitzer can actually see the infrared radiation from the planet. By timing the disappearance of the planet behind the star, Spitzer also can measure the "ellipticity," or "out-of-roundness," of the planet's orbit. If the orbit is elliptical, then the varying gravitational force would result in extra heating of the planet, expanding its atmosphere and perhaps explaining why the object's diameter seems especially large for a body of its calculated mass.
"By timing the planet's passages across the star, both amateur and professional astronomers might be lucky enough to detect the presence of another planet in the XO-1 system by its gravitational tugs on XO-1b. It's even possible that such a planet could be similar to Earth." - Peter McCullough.
A planet transits an11th magnitude, G1V star in the constellation Corna Borealis. We designate the planet XO-1b, and the star, XO-1, also known as SC0241-01657. XO-1 lacks a trigonometric distance; we estimate it to be 200 20pc. Of the ten stars currently known to host extrasolar transiting planets, the star XO-1 is the most similar to the Sun its physical cartelistic: its radius is 1.0±0.8 solar radii:, its mass is 1.0±0.3 solar masses:, Vsini<3kms-1, and its metallicty (Fe/H. is 0.15±0.4) The orbital period of the planet XO-1b is 3.9415340.027 days, one of the longer ones known. The planetary mass is 0.9±0.7MJ, which is marginally larger than that other transiting planets with periods between 3 and 4 days. Both the planetary radius and the inclination are functions of the spectroscopicaly determined stellar radius. If the stellar radius is 1.0±0.8R, then the planetary radius is 1.30±0.1RJ and the inclination of the orbits 87.±1.2°
The HARPS radial velocity measurements of HD 69830 are folded with the orbital periods of the three discovered planets: 8.67, 31.6 and 197 days, respectively. In each case, the contribution of the two other planets has been subtracted. The solid line shows the best fit to the measurements, corresponding to minimum masses of 10.2, 11.8 and 18.1 Earth masses. Note that the full span of the vertical axis is only 13 m/s! Error bars indicate the accuracy of the measurements. The integration time was 4 minutes on average for the first 18 measurements (shown as open dots), and was increased to 15 minutes for the remaining points (full dots). The latter measurements are therefore of much higher quality.
Illustration of the possible formation process and present day structure of the planetary system around HD 68930. The three planets form from embryos originally located at larger distances (dashed ellipses) than the present ones (indicated by solid ellipses at 0.07, 0.18 and 0.63 the mean Earth-Sun distance). The embryos of the inner and middle planets start interior to the ice line, so that these two planets build up from rocky planetesimals and gas. The two planets consist of a central rocky core (in brown) and an envelope of gas. The embryo of the outermost planet starts beyond the ice line, and the planet accumulates a large amount of ice at the beginning of its formation. The planet finally consists of a central rocky core (brown), surrounded by a shell of water (ice or liquid - in blue), and a quite massive gas envelope. Credit: ESO
Three Neptune-sized worlds have been found orbiting a Sun-like star (HD 69830) 41.04 light-years away, in the southern constellation Puppis. The outermost planet is currently the smallest ever found in the “habitable zone” of a Sun-like star, where liquid water could exist.
Position(2000): RA 08:18:23.9 Dec: -12:37:55.8
"The astronomer’s dream would be to be able to study the composition and structure of these planets to see exactly what they look like" - Christophe Lovis, from the Geneva Observatory in Switzerland, whose team made the discovery.
In 2005, the Spitzer Space Telescope detected dust in the HD 69830 system consistent with the existence of an asteroid belt twenty times more massive than that in our own system and lying within the equivalent orbit of Venus. The belt would be so massive that the nights on any nearby planets would be lit up by zodiacal light 1000 times brighter than that seen on Earth, easily outshining the Milky Way.
This graph of data from NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope demonstrates that the dust around a nearby star called HD 69830 (upper line) has a very similar composition to that of Comet Hale-Bopp. Spitzer spotted large amounts of this dust in the inner portion of the HD 69830 system.
The team discovered the planets by monitoring how the parent star wobbles over a period of two years using the 3.6-metre telescope at La Silla Observatory in Chile. HD 69830 (HR 3259 / Gl 302) is a yellow-orange to orange-red, main sequence dwarf star of spectral and luminosity type G7.5-K0 V. The star has a mass of around 80 to 85 percent of Sol's, and 89 percent of its diameter.
The team’s observations suggest the star has three planets, all of which lie closer to their star than the Earth does to the Sun. Their masses are at least 10, 12 and 18 times that of the Earth, respectively.
The two innermost planets are probably rocky and blisteringly hot. But the outermost one lies far enough from the star to be in a habitable zone, centred around 0.75 AU , where liquid water can exist. -- with an orbital period around 197 days.
Christophe Lovis suspects it has a rocky core surrounded by a watery layer.
"Theoretical models suggest that the third planet may indeed contain large amounts of water. Of course, the planet might have moons on which physical conditions could be favourable for life, but this is just speculation. These discoveries give us a hint that low-mass, terrestrial planets are likely to be very common in our galaxy" - Christophe Lovis.
However, the planet probably also has a crushing gassy atmosphere. So the water would be in a high-pressure phase at a temperature above 1000° kelvin.
Title: A Spitzer/IRAC Search for Substellar Companions of the Debris Disk Star epsilon Eridani Authors: M. Marengo, S. T. Megeath, G. G. Fazio, K. R. Stapelfeldt, M. W. Werner, D. E. Backman
We have used the InfraRed Array Camera (IRAC) onboard the Spitzer Space telescope to search for low mass companions of the nearby debris disk star epsilon Eridani. The star was observed in two epochs 39 days apart, with different focal plane rotation to allow the subtraction of the instrumental Point Spread Function, achieving a maximum sensitivity of 0.01 MJy/sr at 3.6 and 4.5 um, and 0.05 MJy/sr at 5.8 and 8.0 um. This sensitivity is not sufficient to directly detect scattered or thermal radiation from the epsilon Eridani debris disk. It is however sufficient to allow the detection of Jovian planets with mass as low as 1 MJ in the IRAC 4.5 um band. In this band, we detected over 460 sources within the 5.70 arcmin field of view of our images. To test if any of these sources could be a low mass companion to epsilon Eridani, we have compared their colours and magnitudes with models and photometry of low mass objects. Of the sources detected in at least two IRAC bands, none fall into the range of mid-IR colour and luminosity expected for cool, 1 Gyr substellar and planetary mass companions of epsilon Eridani, as determined by both models and observations of field M, L and T dwarf. We identify three new sources which have detections at 4.5 um only, the lower limit placed on their (3.6)- (4.5) colour consistent with models of planetary mass objects. Their nature cannot be established with the currently available data and a new observation at a later epoch will be needed to measure their proper motion, in order to determine if they are physically associated to epsilon Eridani.
Epsilon Eridani, 10.5 light-years away, is a star somewhat smaller and cooler than our sun, and is already known to have at least one planet. By some science-fiction accounts, Epsilon Eridani is the parent star for Vulcan, Mr. Spock's home planet on "Star Trek." However, Trekkers have come to favour another star in the same constellation....
The N2K Consortium VI: Doppler Shifts Without Templates and Three New Short-Period Planets Authors: John Asher Johnson, Geoffrey W. Marcy, Debra A. Fischer, Gregory Laughlin, R. Paul Butler, Gregory W. Henry, Jeff A. Valenti, Eric B. Ford, Steven S. Vogt, Jason T. Wright
Researchers present a modification to the iodine cell Doppler technique that eliminates the need for an observed stellar template spectrum. For a given target star, they iterate toward a synthetic template spectrum beginning with an existing spectrum of a similar star. They then perturb the shape of this first-guess template to match the program observation of the target star taken through an iodine cell. The elimination of a separate template observation saves valuable telescope time, a feature that is ideally suited for the quick-look strategy employed by the ''Next 2000 Stars'' (N2K) planet search program. Tests using Keck/HIRES spectra indicate that synthetic templates yield a short-term precision of 3 m/s and a long-term, run-to-run precision of 5 m/s. They used this new Doppler technique to discover three new planets: a 1.5 Jupiter mass planet in a 2.1375 d orbit around HD86081; a 0.71 Jupiter mass planet in circular, 26.73 d orbit around HD224693; and a Saturn-mass planet in an 18.179 d orbit around HD33283. The remarkably short period of HD 86081b bridges the gap between the extremely short-period planets detected in the OGLE survey and the 16 Doppler-detected hot Jupiters (P less than 15 d), which have an orbital period distribution that piles up at about three days. The researchers have acquired photometric observations of two of the planetary host stars with the automated photometric telescopes at Fairborn Observatory. HD 86081 and HD 224693 both lack detectable brightness variability on their radial velocity periods, supporting planetary-reflex motion as the cause of the radial velocity variability. HD 86081 shows no evidence of planetary transits in spite of a 17.6% transit probability.
Title: Microlens OGLE-2005-BLG-169 Implies Cool Neptune-Like Planets are Common Authors: A. Gould, A. Udalski, D. An, D.P. Bennett, A.-Y. Zhou, S. Dong, N.J. Rattenbury, B.S. Gaudi, P.C.M. Yock, I.A. Bond, G.W. Christie, K. Horne, J. Anderson, K.Z. Stanek, D.L. DePoy, C. Han, J. McCormick, B.-G. Park, R.W. Pogge, S.D. Poindexter, I. Soszynski, M.K. Szymanski, M. Kubiak, G. Pietrzynski, O. Szewczyk, L. Wyrzykowski, K. Ulaczyk, B. Paczynski, D.M. Bramich, C. Snodgrass, I.A. Steele, M.J. Burgdorf, M.F. Bode, C.S. Botzler, S. Mao, S.C. Swaving (The MicroFUN, OGLE, and PLANET/RoboNet collaborations)
We detect a Neptune mass-ratio (q = 8 x 10^-5) planetary companion to the lens star in the extremely high-magnification (A~800) microlensing event OGLE-2005-BLG-169. If the parent is a main-sequence star, it has mass M~0.5 solar masses implying a planet mass of ~13 earth masses and projected separation of ~2.7 AU. When intensely monitored over their peak, high-magnification events similar to OGLE-2005-BLG-169 have nearly complete sensitivity to Neptune mass-ratio planets with projected separations of 0.6 to 1.6 Einstein radii, corresponding to 1.6--4.3 AU in the present case. Only two other such events were monitored well enough to detect Neptunes, and so this detection by itself suggests that Neptune mass-ratio planets are common. Moreover, another Neptune was recently discovered at a similar distance from its parent star in a low-magnification event, which are more common but are individually much less sensitive to planets. Combining the two detections yields 90% upper and lower frequency limits f=0.37^{+0.30}_{-0.21} over just 0.4 decades of planet-star separation. In particular, f>16% at 90% confidence. The parent star hosts no Jupiter-mass companions with projected separations within a factor 5 of that of the detected planet. The lens-source relative proper motion is µ ~ 7–10mas/yr, implying that if the lens is sufficiently bright, I<23.8, it will be detectable by HST by 3 years after peak. This would permit a more precise estimate of the lens mass and distance, and so the mass and projected separation of the planet. Analogues of OGLE-2005-BLG-169Lb orbiting nearby stars would be difficult to detect by other methods of planet detection, including radial velocities, transits, or astrometry.
Data and bestfit model of OGLE-2005-BLG-169. Lower panel shows difference between this model and a single-lens model with the same (t0, u0, tE, p). It displays the classical form of a caustic entrance/exit that is often seen in binary microlensing events, where the amplitudes and timescales are several orders of magnitude larger than seen here. MDM data trace the characteristic slope change at the caustic exit (delta t = 0.092) extremely well, while the entrance is tracked by a single point (Delta t = -0.1427). The dashed line indicates the time t0. Inset shows source path through the caustic geometry and indicates the source size, p.